The Chery On Top

The AA recently received an alarming complaint from a member.

The member, an owner of a Jetour T1, presented the AA with documented evidence of “torsion rippling deformations (dents) in the roof side panels and around the margins/fringes of the panoramic sunroof” on his brand-new Jetour T1. The deformations surfaced while undertaking some mild weekend gravel off roading in the Dullstroom area. The member mentioned that nothing has ever been mounted, tied or affixed to the roof of the vehicle, and supports these claims through legally commissioned affidavits from parties present on the weekend.

The member appointed a senior independent vehicle assessor, with the feedback equally alarming: 

“Based upon my inspection, my observations and over 36 years of experience as a qualified Auto Body Repairer, Forensic Motor Assessor and Technical Consultant, it is my professional opinion that the consistency, orientation and repetition of the roof side panel rippling observed on this vehicle are both unusual and technically significant. In particular, the highly uniform 45-degree resonance pattern present along the left-hand roof side panel is, in my opinion, a clear manifestation of internally generated torsional stresses acting within the vehicle's monocoque body structure, rather than the result of external influence or isolated panel irregularities.

“The degree of local panel flexibility observed during the inspection, together with the repetitive deformation pattern, is not representative of the structural behaviour expected of a new vehicle and strongly suggests a deficiency in the stiffness characteristics of the upper roof side structure. I therefore conclude that the body shell, in the area inspected, does not exhibit the level of structural rigidity that would reasonably be expected of a vehicle of this age and specification, and that this condition warrants immediate engineering investigation by Jetour South Africa to determine the underlying manufacturing or design defect.

“In my professional opinion, the deformation observed is sufficiently characteristic to raise concern that other Jetour T1 vehicles may exhibit similar stress-related deformation. I therefore recommend that the manufacturer conduct a fleet-wide engineering assessment to determine the prevalence and root cause of this condition.”

The Motor Industry Ombudsman of South Africa (MIOSA), after considering a report from both parties, sides with our member, mentioning that the complainant’s investigator “found that the indentations on the roof side panels and along both sides of the panoramic sunroof are not representative of normal structural behaviour for a new vehicle and are more consistent with a body shell stiffness or manufacturing-related defect than with external influence”.

MIOSA has asked, in terms of Section 53 of the Consumer Protection Act, that the Chery Group brand “accept the vehicle into its stock and replace it with another similar vehicle of similar age and mileage”. The Chery Group is appealing the MIOSA ruling, and MIOSA has since appointed a technical expert to investigate the case further. MIOSA points out that ‘defect’ means any material imperfection in the manufacture of the goods or components, or in performance of the services, that renders the goods or results of the service less acceptable than persons generally would be reasonably entitled to expect in the circumstances.

The disappointed member concludes his concerns to the AA by saying: “I encourage T1 owners to do a thumb test on their vehicle roof panels, you will notice that simple finger pressure can result in visible indents. I know of a few other such cases and have no doubt that Jetour owners will be coming forward with similar concerns in the near future. We are unable to use the vehicle for the purposes for which it was marketed and sold, namely the lifestyle and adventure capabilities prominently advertised under tags and themes such as #FearlessExplorer, #TheRelentlessAdventurer, #AdventureReady and #SUVGoals.”

The AA engaged Jetour SA, who confirmed that: “We are further investigating this matter with MIOSA and remain committed to resolving this matter fairly through the proper channels”.

For the AA this is yet another case of a structural integrity concern with the Jetour T1 / T2 range. The AA recently questioned the validity of the National Regulator for Compulsory Specifications (NRCS) approval of the updated payload (load-carrying) capacity of 475kg, inclusive of the driver, for the Jetour T1 and T2 passenger vehicles.

The concerns raised by the AA are threefold: the validity of the revised payload figures from an initial rating of 300kg to 475kg (with no mechanical upgrades), the fact that the rating applies to new and existing models on our roads, and that the NRCS grants these approvals based on global lab reports submitted by the automaker, as opposed to local and independent verification.

Of greater concern is that the NRCS confirmed that Jetour’s application for the revised payload rating for the T1 is still in the approval process, meaning that both new and existing T1 customers are still subject to the vehicle’s original homologated payload rating of 300kg. This contradicted what the automaker stated a few weeks prior, claiming at the end of August that “based on the approval obtained from the NRCS, Jetour South Africa confirms that the approved payload capacity applicable to the relevant Jetour T1 and T2 model range is 475 kg, inclusive of the driver”.

Jetour further stated at the time that the “T2’s structural platform was engineered and validated, from the outset, to withstand technical masses considerably higher than its original 300kg global payload rating”. The AA maintains that increasing a payload by almost 200kg (58% increase) with no attention to structural integrity remains a safety concern for local owners.

The AA’s internal case records also show a worrying reliability trend. As a past roadside assistance service provider for the broader Chery Group (Chery, Omoda, Jaecoo, iCaur, and Lepas) the AA’s call centre stats show 11 070 call outs over the last twelve months alone. This number excludes cases involving locksmith issues and flat tyres - the number is indicative of various real mechanical issues requiring an AA patrolman to assist or an AA tow to a workshop. 

Adding further concern is the NCC last week announcing the recall of more than 23,000 Chery and Omoda vehicles for a rear-axle welding fault on the Tiggo 4 and Omoda C5 and a brake pipe that can wear against the turbocharger on the Tiggo 8 Pro Max. Prior to this, when consumer journalist Wendy Knowler checked in October, only one Chinese-owned brand appeared in this year’s recall notices from the National Consumer Commission (NCC). 

The NCC has further confirmed that Chery has effectively been running what it calls silent recalls. On 25 June, Chery told its dealers to treat the campaign as a priority, contact affected customers and check unsold stock. The public was not told until the NCC’s notice on 10 November, 138 days later. The NCC has now said publicly that it is investigating Chery over allegations of earlier recalls that were not reported to it.

“The AA has spent the greater part of this year questioning the Chery group’s product quality, insisting time and again that the NRCS, NCC and the public at large hold the Chinese OEM accountable both from a safety and quality standpoint,” says Bobby Ramagwede, CEO of the Automobile Association of South Africa. 

“We are reaching a watershed moment, with the AA once again asking the bodies commissioned to look after the safety of the consumer to do exactly that. We need real, decisive action, we also need consumers to firmly demand better from the Chery group. Has the time come for consumers to simply hand their Chery products back to banks and dealerships?”

The AA asks the South African motorist to prioritise safer mobility. The AA strives for the safety and wellbeing of the South African motorist, if you are a member and have a consumer issue that is in need of our urgent mediation, please email This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. – we are at your side in every step of your ongoing mobility journey. 

Become a member today and help us help you.